DF

"Dave Falls"

26/04/2004 12:27 PM

Floor nailer - Bostich or Porter Cable

Any comments on which is better, more durable?
Any feedback would be appreciated.
thanks


This topic has 5 replies

MC

"Master Chef Richard Campbell"

in reply to "Dave Falls" on 26/04/2004 12:27 PM

26/04/2004 8:03 PM

I have the PC and it has been a Tank. Less than a dozen jambs in more than
4000 square feet of oak and Brazilian cherry.

Chef


"MattH" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> "Dave Falls" <[email protected]> wrote in news:3f7jc.280427$2oI1.217293
> @twister01.bloor.is.net.cable.rogers.com:
>
> > Any comments on which is better, more durable?
> > Any feedback would be appreciated.
> > thanks
> >
> >
> >
>
> Bostitch is the gold standard. The MIIIFS is a tank, which is why it's so
> commonly found for rent. You can easily find the staples - cheap - even
at
> the BORG. I'm sure that the Porter Cable is a good unit, too, but it
> doesn't appear to be as common. I bought a used Bostitch on eBay for
about
> $250. After I'm done putting in about 1500 sq-ft of Brazilian cherry,
I'll
> sell it on eBay for about $250.
> Matt

EP

"Edwin Pawlowski"

in reply to "Dave Falls" on 26/04/2004 12:27 PM

26/04/2004 8:36 PM


"Master Chef Richard Campbell" <[email protected]> wrote in
message
...
> I have the PC and it has been a Tank. Less than a dozen jambs in more than
> 4000 square feet of oak and Brazilian cherry.

But isn't the target ZERO jams per 4,000 square feet? I honestly don't know
if a dozen is good or not by comparison.
Ed

MN

MattH

in reply to "Dave Falls" on 26/04/2004 12:27 PM

26/04/2004 1:38 PM

"Dave Falls" <[email protected]> wrote in news:3f7jc.280427$2oI1.217293
@twister01.bloor.is.net.cable.rogers.com:

> Any comments on which is better, more durable?
> Any feedback would be appreciated.
> thanks
>
>
>

Bostitch is the gold standard. The MIIIFS is a tank, which is why it's so
commonly found for rent. You can easily find the staples - cheap - even at
the BORG. I'm sure that the Porter Cable is a good unit, too, but it
doesn't appear to be as common. I bought a used Bostitch on eBay for about
$250. After I'm done putting in about 1500 sq-ft of Brazilian cherry, I'll
sell it on eBay for about $250.
Matt

An

Ajax

in reply to "Dave Falls" on 26/04/2004 12:27 PM

06/05/2004 7:28 PM

The Bostich flooring stapler is about the most popular flooring
machine in our local market - Charlotte, NC. It is durable and
reliable. Parts and service are also readily available.

Pete

On Mon, 26 Apr 2004 12:27:43 GMT, "Dave Falls" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>Any comments on which is better, more durable?
>Any feedback would be appreciated.
>thanks
>

Rb

Renata

in reply to "Dave Falls" on 26/04/2004 12:27 PM

28/04/2004 7:59 AM

My impression - which I'm finding may be wrong, is that PC is less
oriented toward the pro. But, here's a recent experience...

Just finished my roof. Had a borrowed PC coil roofing nailer. When I
started out, the thing was nothing but trouble. Jammed frequently,
had to follow up half the nails with a couple whacks of the hammer.
Things were taking a LONG time. Roof looked like it was gonna be a
perpetual project.
Then, I figured out how to use the dang thing. The jamming stopped by
itself for whatever reason. Maybe my bad attitude was conveying to
the nailer and when I chilled it did too. And, miracle of miracles,
bounce nailing did the trick with getting the nails set to proper
depth (pressure had been ok all along, it was user error basically).

Now, this is but one roof and it may that they're not as durable for a
pro doing several houses a year. But, if you're Harry Homeowner, I'd
say it seems PC is perfectly acceptable.

Renata



On Mon, 26 Apr 2004 20:36:02 GMT, "Edwin Pawlowski" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>
>"Master Chef Richard Campbell" <[email protected]> wrote in
>message
>...
>> I have the PC and it has been a Tank. Less than a dozen jambs in more than
>> 4000 square feet of oak and Brazilian cherry.
>
>But isn't the target ZERO jams per 4,000 square feet? I honestly don't know
>if a dozen is good or not by comparison.
>Ed
>


You’ve reached the end of replies